Kayak Fishing Ultimate Resource

Tuesday, 13 May 2014 09:19

No One is Hurting You

Written by
Rate this item
(16 votes)

Another week goes by and another 12 debates erupt on the internet about whether pedal kayaks are actually kayaks. Paddlers take up their side, pedalers take their side and the war of what is “right” rages on.

In an internet forum or Facebook wall it rages on.

This was the hot topic for my inbox this week so I’ll give my thoughts on the pedal vs paddle debate. Ready? Here goes.

Can we be done with this? All week I get emails about which I think is the truest form of kayaking from paddlers. All week I get messages from the pedal folks about how short sighted the paddlers are about moving into the future.

I’ll say it: This is the new Ford vs Chevy vs Dodge vs Toyota debate.

My answer to all this? Stop it. No one is in the right or wrong here.

photographs provided by Hobie Cat and Chris Funk

If you like to paddle that’s great but belittling someone because they aren’t a “purist” (your words not mine) is silly. I don’t see you in a sit in kayak made from seal skins and whale bone so stop it.

If you think pedals are superior and you tell everyone you know about it, please stop. We get it. You can afford a more expensive kayak and have the luxuries of speed and trolling while sipping your coffee. We know. We have seen the commercials and heard you talk about it incessantly.

The fact of the matter is it all comes down to physics. Sure sometimes a paddle will win and sometimes a pedal will win. All things being equal, which is a misnomer in itself, the pedals are going to win a majority of the time.

Having pride in what kayak you use is good. Being boastful and belittling towards others is not.

The bottom line is, get a piece of plastic, a pfd, a whistle and get out there.

If you can’t be nice, keep your mouth shut. No one is hurting you by having a different kayak. Lots of people want the sport to grow and this is first step. Be ok in your skin. Be ok with others choices because if someone is on the water and safe, that should be enough.

You don’t need to create armies of followers who bought the same kayak you did. The world won’t end if they go a different direction. It doesn’t mean they don’t like you.

The responses to this are predictable and that’s ok. Dozens of people will comment publicly and privately that this is not how they operate. I gotcha. You guys are the good ones. Today I am talking to the loud obnoxious ones who stereotype anyone who uses a different mode of propulsion than they do.

To those guys, please stop. All kayakers should be welcomed into our sport whether paddle, pedal, sail or electric motor. Yeah, I said it. Get out and fish and leave the drama to the soap operas. 

Read 5180 times Last modified on Friday, 16 May 2014 07:32
Chris Payne

I've been fishing over 30 years and the majority of my time on the water has been spent in Texas with the occasional trips out of state. In 2003 I bought my first kayak and a new era in my fishing life was born. I learned the ropes quickly about gear, paddling, fishing, packing, safety and got a degree from the school of hard knocks with a major in kayak fishing. I learned a lot of ways to not do something.

I love kayak fishing and I want to share it with as many people as possible. That's the bottom line. 


Social Profiles


+1 # Will Richardson 2014-05-13 10:40

This also goes for the guys who think that motherships are not pure.. offshore kayaking isn’t as pure as back creek kayaking, anyone that hates some other facet of the sport and feels the need to belittle others over it.

Great article Chris
# paynefish 2014-07-15 09:05
Quoting Will Richardson:

This also goes for the guys who think that motherships are not pure.. offshore kayaking isn’t as pure as back creek kayaking, anyone that hates some other facet of the sport and feels the need to belittle others over it.

Great article Chris

Thanks Will. Not enough room in this world for Hobby Hate
+2 # wildrover 2014-05-13 14:54
AMEN :lol:
I couldn't agree more. Best of all, I have one of each. LOL
+1 # WildernessWomen 2014-05-13 20:12
said in honest words, Thanks!!
+2 # SighGone 2014-05-14 11:11
I have both versions too. To me, it's the right equipment for the right circumstances. Personally, I could care less what others label or try to define as a "purist". It should all be about getting out and enjoying the outdoors and family / friend time- paddling, peddling, fishing.
# sokyfishing 2014-05-16 13:12
Well said.
# KayakFisher1967 2014-05-25 10:46
OK, we get it....you can step down from your soap box now.

I have an Outback, but certain salt ponds that I fish in have shallow areas so shallow that I have to resort to using the PADDLE just to head out to the deeper portion of the pond. I have 1 kayak and I use both methods based on judgement.

Please login to post a comment.

Get the YakAngler Newsletter!

Keep tabs on all the latest from YakAngler.

Latest From The Forum

    • dajeanpi's Avatar
    • Which kayak to choose?
    • Hey Kayakers, if you have a minute, help out by filling out my quick google survey on a concept Kayak Transport Device! All responses are much...
    • 16 hours 1 minute ago
    • tbarcia's Avatar
    • Sonar mapping with Garmin
    • I have two different Garmin plotters, the EchoMap 50s that's in my bowrider and the GPSMAP 440s that's on the SUP. What I'm wondering is if there is...
    • 18 hours 10 minutes ago
    • Crow Horse's Avatar
    • Kayak Cart Tow Bar......
    • Thanks.... I used it today and it worked quite well. I had so much more control while descending the trail. It made it heaps easier and at this stage...
    • 1 day 9 hours ago

More Topics »